Text of the GOP Response to President Clinton's State of the Union Address
January 19, 1999
Dunn: Good evening, I'm Jennifer Dunn. I represent the people of the
8th District of Washington state.
Largent: And I'm Steve Largent from the 1st District of Oklahoma.
Dunn:
As you might imagine - if you'd been sitting with us in the
House Chamber tonight as the president was giving his speech - you
could have felt the swirl of history, These are disturbing and
controversial times in our nation's capital.
A couple of weeks ago, I heard a network anchor say, "The
capital is in chaos." Another proclaimed we were in the midst of a
constitutional crisis.
Ladies and gentlemen, our country is not in crisis. There are no
tanks in the streets. Our system of government is as solid as the
Capitol dome you see behind me.
Our democracy is sound. Our economy is prosperous. The State of
our Union is strong. And no matter what the outcome of the
president's situation, life in America will go on. Our lives will
continue to be filled with practical matters, not constitutional
ones.
I've been a single mother since my boys were little - 6 and 8.
My life in those days was taken up with making ends meet, trying to
get to two soccer games at the same time on two different fields,
worrying about dropping the boys off early at school in order to
get to work on time. I know how that knot in the pit of your
stomach feels. I've been there.
I'm still a practical person.
You heard the president make a lot of promises to a lot of
people tonight, but I'd like to talk to you about two very
practical Republican priorities - tax relief and Social Security
reform.
Our current tax system is a burden on the economy and on the
American people. Let me tell you a story about a fellow I represent
from North Bend, Wash. His name is Robert Allan.
A few years ago, the IRS denied his right to file a joint return
with his wife, because they said his wife Shirley was deceased.
Well, I've seen Shirley - she looks pretty good for a dead person!
Robert took Shirley to the IRS office in Seattle. The IRS was
not convinced. So the Allans brought in their family doctor, who in
his medical opinion pronounced Shirley alive - the IRS was still
not convinced.
It took intervention by a member of Congress, me, to resolve
this comedy, which in truth is a tragedy because it's symbolic of
how removed our entire tax system has become from reality and
common sense.
Last year, we passed legislation reining in the IRS - so that
taxpayers are now considered innocent until proven guilty. But so
much more needs to be done.
Next year there will be a $63 billion-dollar budget surplus. Mr.
President, give it back. Last year, a typical mother and father who
both work paid nearly 40 percent of their income in taxes - that
means 40 cents of every dollar they earned went to the government
in federal, state or local taxes - that's the highest percentage of
income ever paid in taxes by American families.
I don't know about you but that really bothers me; no wonder so
many American families are struggling:
Get married, and your taxes go up.
Save for your children's education, and your taxes go up.
And when you die - that's right - your taxes go up. The
government gets a bigger piece of your life's work than all your
children put together. So what can you expect from Republicans?
Expect action.
First, tonight we're proposing a 10 percent, across-the-board
cut in tax rates for every working American. That is the down
payment on a simpler, fairer, flatter tax system.
Second, we must end the marriage penalty. We should honor
commitment, not tax it.
And third, we must cut death taxes so that families don't have
to sell their businesses and farms when Mom and Dad die.
In all our tax policies, we start from this premise: The
people's money belongs to the people, not to the government.
The second thing I want to talk about is Social Security. A year
ago in his State of the Union speech, the president said he was
committed to saving Social Security. I'm glad to hear him discuss
it again this evening. We are interested in his ideas on how to
spend the surplus. Unfortunately, the president still hasn't given
us his plan to save Social Security.
Mr. President, we're still waiting for that legislation.
Social Security will begin to go bankrupt in about 15 years - if
we don't find solutions now. We have reserved H.R. 1 - the very
first bill of this Congress - for the president's Social Security
plan.
Words may be a comfort, but we need action. There's one thing we
can all agree on - one nonnegotiable principle - we must keep our
contract with our senior citizens who depend on Social Security for
part or all of their retirement income, This nation made that
promise long ago and we will keep that promise.
But Social Security needs not just to be saved; it needs to be
updated for the 21st century. People today want and expect to have
more control over their lives and their money. But President
Clinton's approach, as you've just heard, gives the government more
control of your retirement income.
The Social Security dollars deducted from your paycheck
currently earn less than 3 percent a year. That's not enough of a
return; that's not going to keep Social Security solvent; and it's
especially not fair to young people and women. For example, the
current system works against mothers who choose to step out of
their job for a while, away from their career, to raise children or
to care for parents.
It works against wives, who more often than not, survive their
husbands and end up living for more years on fewer dollars. And it
works against young people who believe they'll never see a Social
Security check.
Here's a better way: Give working Americans the choice to invest
some of their Social Security dollars in personal retirement
accounts. We can do this without touching a dime in Social Security
funds - without raising one nickel in taxes - without touching one
penny of current benefits.
A new century requires a new beginning - in approaches, in
ideas, and, yes, in civility and cooperation between political
parties.
I'd like to close on a personal note. I'm a mother, a gardener,
a Republican and a member of Congress. Believe me, all four take
patience.
My boys thankfully turned out to be wonderful young men. My
plants at home unfortunately need a lot of work. And as for my
efforts in the Congress, I am constantly planting and watering.
And as one citizen to another, in spite of all the troubling
things you hear about our nation's capital, I believe that good
ideas can take root here, good things can grow here and good things
can blossom here.
Steve Largent:
Thanks, Jennifer. Again, my name is Steve Largent and I
represent Oklahoma's 1st Congressional District. Tonight, I want to
share some brief, but important, thoughts with you.
First, let me say what a special privilege it is to speak to you
and give my response and the Republican response to the president's
remarks.
Let me tell you a bit about myself. I grew up in Oklahoma and
was born in the very district I'm now proud to represent. I was
raised in a broken home and thanks to my Mom, I stayed in school,
stayed out of most trouble, and went to college. I married my high
school sweetheart, Terry, a cheerleader. And, for the next 14
years, I got to live every boy's dream - playing in the National
Football League for the Seattle Seahawks.
After I concluded my career in the NFL, I started my own
marketing and advertising business back in Tulsa. But in 1994 I
campaigned for the first elective office in my life and won. I came
to Washington with a group of Republicans committed to balancing
the budget, slowing the growth of government, cutting taxes,
reforming welfare and saving Medicare. And that's exactly what we
did.
But as Babe Ruth once said, "Yesterday's home runs don't win
today's games."
It's time to step up to the plate once again.
Prior to 1994, my wife and I were not political. We were like
most families - raising four kids, hustling from one school or
sports event to another, our car littered by fast-food wrappers and
French fries. In fact, it wasn't until after I was elected that I
attended a Republican function where a banner hung that read
"GOP." I had to ask what those letters stood for.
They said, "Grand Old Party, of course."
I believe tonight is an appropriate time to ask once again, what
does the GOP stand for? What does the party of Lincoln and Reagan
stand for today? What are the lasting bedrock principles that
personify and distinguish the Republican party? It's these
questions I want to answer tonight because the answer is why I ran
for office in the first place.
Here's the 15-second sound bite answer - the Republican party's
mission is to promote, preserve, and protect individual liberty,
free enterprise and limited government. But what does that mean to
my family and your family?
INDIVIDUAL LIBERTY
First, we must preserve the notion that true liberty and freedom
come from God and are his blessing on this land and that freedom
reigns only as we act responsibly toward God, each other, and his
creation. Our freedom was bought at a great price, and our most
important responsibility is to defend this sacred gift and keep our
country secure. Tonight we support our troops that are stationed in
Bosnia, the Middle East and around the world. And the good news is
that after six years of cutting spending for our armed forces, the
president has signaled that he is ready to join us in strengthening
our national defense.
We must never be complacent in what is still a dangerous world.
Terrorists and rogue nations are rapidly acquiring technology to
deliver weapons of mass destruction to our very doorstep. Most
Americans are shocked to discover that our country is unshielded
from the accidental or ruthless launch of even a single missile
over our skies. Mr. President, we urge you to join Congress in
establishing a viable missile defense system to protect the United
States.
Protecting individual liberty also means protecting the unborn.
Again this year, overwhelming majorities in both houses will urge
the president to end the dreadful and unwarranted practice of
partial-birth abortion. We must uphold the sanctity of life amidst
the tragedies of abortion, euthanasia, and assisted suicide.
FREE ENTERPRISE
Republicans also promote free enterprise. We believe market
principles like competition work. At the heart of free enterprise
is good education. For far too long we've allowed Washington to
dictate how our children are taught. One of our priorities is to
give control of our schools to local communities, We want the most
important election affecting your children's education to be the
one that decides who sits on the school board, not who you send to
Washington. Parents deserve the opportunity to choose the best
school, with the best curriculum, best teachers, and safest
environment for their children.
I recently met with a room full of teachers in Jenks, Okla. I
came out of that meeting convinced more than ever that teachers
like these know best how federal education dollars should be spent.
That's why Republicans are leading the effort that will ensure 90
cents of every federal education dollar goes directly to the
classroom, empowering parents and teachers, not bureaucrats.
And if we really want to "free" enterprise and the economy,
let's scrap the Internal Revenue tax code. The 8,000-plus pages of
confusion, contradiction and confiscation are choking small
business and driving the average taxpayer mad. Republicans want to
establish a date by which the tax code will be abolished and
replaced by something that's simple, fair, and takes a smaller bite
from the family's pocket book.
LIMITED GOVERNMENT
Finally, Republicans stand for limited government. Ronald Reagan
warned that "a government that is big enough to give you
everything you want is also big enough to take everything you
have." And tonight the federal government is still too big and
taking more than it should. We will continue our efforts to control
Washington's wasteful spending and its insatiable appetite for your
money.
Well, this is what the Grand Old Party stands for and if this
represents your hopes and dreams, we ask not that you pull for us,
but that you push with us.
RECONCILIATION
Back in my district, Oklahomans are steeped in America's deep
tradition of faith, family, hard work and strong neighborhoods,
They represent the values that hold communities together, And they
believe in the power of a better tomorrow. There's still a lot to
be done, But I, too, am more optimistic than ever, These last four
years have given me the unique opportunity to witness the grit and
determination of the American people - our greatest resource.
Yesterday marked the 70th year since the birth of a great
American leader and hero, Dr. Martin Luther King, In one of his
last sermons in 1968, Dr. King warned that, while the world is a
closer neighborhood, we are experiencing less brotherhood. That's
just as true today. It is no longer the aggression from without
that is America's greatest threat, but alienation from within;
alienation at every level - husband from wife, mother from father,
parent from child, black from white, Republican from Democrat,
liberal from conservative.
There is only one solution - reconciliation. Ironically, the
word Congress itself is made of two Latin words that mean "to walk
together." Reconciliation requires the humility and courage to
say, "I'm sorry, I was wrong, will you forgive me." Therein lies
the healing salve for the wounded soul of our nation. You see, the
body of our country is strong. It's the heart that needs attention.
On Christmas Eve my family and I packed up kids and gifts and
headed to Grandma's house. In the car we sang along with Vince
Gill's Christmas tape. As we sang one particular song, I was struck
by the words and by their poignancy for our country tonight. The
chorus went, "Let there be peace on Earth, and let it begin with
me."
So, let there be peace on Earth, and let it begin with me. Let
it begin with Republicans and Democrats and blacks and whites, moms
and especially dads. Let there be peace on Earth and let it begin
with all of us who comprise one nation, under God, indivisible.
And if we work together and walk together, and if we have a
Congress motivated not by the maintenance of power, but principle,
then I believe historians will tell our children's children: There
walked a great people, a nation that preserved the wonderful
promise that we call America.
Thank you for taking a few moments tonight. May God bless you
and your family, and may God continue to bless this great nation.
Thank you for listening. Good night.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|